|
Madness Explained: Psychosis and Human Nature | 
 enlarge | Author: Richard P Bentall
Publisher: Penguin
Category: Book
List Price: £12.99
Buy New: £6.67
You Save: £6.32 (49%)
New (32) Used (10) from £6.00
Avg. Customer Rating:  9 reviews
Sales Rank: 12312
Media: Paperback
Edition: New Ed
Number Of Items: 1
Pages: 656
Shipping Weight (lbs): 1
Dimensions (in): 7.7 x 4.9 x 1.3
ISBN: 0140275401
Dewey Decimal Number: 362
EAN: 9780140275407
ASIN: 0140275401
Publication Date: April 29, 2004
Availability: Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days
|
| Also Available In:
|
| Similar Items:
|
| Customer Reviews: Read 4 more reviews...
 Could have been better. November 8, 2008
Maybe it was me. Maybe working in Mental Health Care with people diagnosed with inconsistent and inaccurate labels distances me from much of what Richard Bentall writes here. The first part of this book was inspiring and informative. Then Bentall (the self confessed academic who lives in his ivory tower completely lost my interest. He became enmeshed in statistics and counter claims which have established medicine as the police force of mental illness.
The first half is excellent, the second half is of use to academics only. It's a shame really. There are other more inspiring reads for the working mental health professional. Try Gamble and Brennan instead.
 excellent and readable March 19, 2008
this is an excellent book which is both readable and yet gets into complexity of the issues
 Psychiatrists - Do not be afraid! February 16, 2007
44 out of 45 found this review helpful
Confession 1:I am a Psychiatrist.
Confession 2: Before I started this book I was expecting a deeply negative perception of modern psychiatry and little in the way of concrete evidence to support any alternative hypothesis. I anticipated this book to he read mainly by other psychologists, anti-psychiatrists and disgruntled patients.
However, I rapidly discovered that this is not the start of a new anti-psychiatry movement but in fact a fascinating, open-minded review of the current thinking about madness.
The first third of this book should be read by everyone involved in or interested in psychiatry, psychology, or just madness. It is a brilliant and genuinely gripping synthesis of the journey from dark age beliefs about madness to the current concepts. The author makes this potentially dreary history lesson vibrant, relevant and insightful and brings alive many of the key players whose legacies have outlived them, whether deservedly or not.
After this the author then goes on to explore in quite significant detail, the psychological and biological research into psychosis and related conditions. This is predictably heavier going but worth persevering with for the exciting and occasionally startling revelations.
As a result, he fairly comprehensively dismantles the traditional model of psychiatric classification but manages to bring even the most sceptical reader with him through this process.I did not find this as controversial as I expected, as most practising psychiatrists are already aware of the significant overlap in diagnoses and symptoms of these disorders. Richard Bentall then formulates draft models for approaching particular psychiatric symptoms.
There is much less controversial material in this book than I expected. The research discussed is reasonably balanced and the conclusions are tentative and never fundamentalist.
However, although interesting, evidence-based and realistic, the practical applications of the symptom-directed approach are not at all clear. Abandoning traditional psychiatric diagnoses altogether would at present leave patients, carers and health professionals with even less framework for approaching treatment, suggesting aetiology or predicting prognosis. This book may encourage us to be more flexible and patient-centred but I cannot yet see it changing frontline mental health care.
Vital subject matter, lucid writing, great reading. February 12, 2007
8 out of 9 found this review helpful
This is a great book regardless of whether you would like to understand madness or psychosis. It is an example of a well researched, well written, entertaning, interdisciplinairy take on a complex, fascinating and much misunderstood element of human experience. Some of the reviews here state their own preferences to approaching the subject and cite limitations in Bentall's own (self-aware) attempts to comprehend the phenomena of 'madness' from his own scientific/social agenda but so what? This book opens the door to new avenues of comprehending human experience as it in the very least shows the variety of ways in which human beings attempt to comprehend who we are and the limitations of the perspectives we offer. No right answers are on offer here but a critical, entertaining and accessible (and pretty comprehensive) survey of data so you can begin to start making your own mind up. Perhaps the best start for engaging with the themes of Psychosis and Madness.
Post-Kraepelinian Approach to Madness! September 6, 2005
32 out of 35 found this review helpful
"Madness explained" is an excellent example of a new synthesis, which assertively, and of course scientifically, challenges the dehumanizing approach to mental health that dominated the mainstream of psychiatric practice over the last hundred years. By reviewing an impressive amount of scientific literature, Bentall argues that there are not any scientific evidence to suggest that biological changes in the brain are the primary cause of madness. These biochemical changes, Bentall argures, might be part of the brain's response to emotional trauma. He rejects the dualistic approach in investigating madness and propose a more scientific, and humanistic alternative, which embraces data from all other disciplines namely, neuroscience, anthropology, sociology and psychology. Bentall also shows how categorical classification of psychological disorders has limited our understanding of the real nature of psychological disorders. He argues that by focusing on patients' complaints (symptoms),rather than focusing on invalid labelles, such as schizophrenia we can identify underlying psychological mechanisms, which are responsible for these meaningful symptoms. I recommend this book to anybody who wants to have a better understanding of psychosis.
|
|
|
Powered by Associate-O-Matic
| |
